Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Sssshhhhh - did we just have good housing data?




With the markets currently wholly dictated to by to-ings and fro-ings on several debt issues around the globe, its largely gone un-noticed that the weekly/macro data is still ongoing and can give us some clues as to what is going on with the economy.



Yesterday's release included the Building Permits and Construction starts data in the US. As a reminder, the building permits is a monthly data that shows the annualized number of permits for new construction projects issued by the Government. Housing Starts is also released monthly, and shows the annualized number of new homes that began construction in the given month. Yesterday, the June data was released. Housing permits: 624,000 and housing starts 629,000.



So why is that good news?








The graph above shows the housing permits and starts over the last 10 years. The 2006 peak, 2009 trough decline of 1.5 million was of epic proportions, in the sense that it was the 3rd worst decline on a population adjusted basis in the last 85 years. However, we have seemingly been bouncing along the bottom since then. At the peak, the housing sector was a major source of growth for the economy; the decline since then has contributed in no small part to the weak growth and high unemployment. However, with the passing of time, slowly but surely it is no longer a drag on the economy. Its not much of a growth booster either, but at least its not a drag. We have been bouncing along the bottom, sort of in neutral territory. .



Remembering though that being that the data is a monthly reading, it is quite "noisy". If we were to zoom in to the housing permits since the end of 2008, but averaging the monthly reading to give a quarterly reading to smooth out the noise, we would get the following graph:







We can see that after an improvement of 125,000 between the beginning of 2009 and the beginning of 2010, most of that gain (100,000) was subsequently given back in the following year. Analyzing post world war 2 housing recessions, it is fair to state that it takes about a year to a year and a half for the full effect of a housing decline to ripple its way through the rest of the economy. With the most recent decline ending in June 2010, it is also fair to say that we may well be close in time for that decline to have been fully felt. With yesterdays, strong readings, the Q2 2011 housing permits and starts, will average over 600,000 (the above graph as taken from the Fed's website ends Q1 2011). That would make it the best quarter for over a year.



True, it may be a one off wonder. However, the difference with the 2009 advance, is that this one is without the artificial stimulation of a housing credit stimulus.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Yields on a one way journey

I have noted in previous posts that with the end of QE, the only way to go in terms of yields is up. The Fed was by far and away the dominant buyer of Tresuries, and in the absence of a different buyer to step up and take their place, price would undlubtedly fall (and yields rise).
Thats taking a look on the demand side. What about on the supply side? Since 16th May, total US debt has been flat at $14.345 billion, due to the restriction of the debt ceiling. Presumably, after much political fighting, the debt ceiling will be raised once more. At which time, the Treasury will not only issue as much debt as before, but massively more in the short term to catchup with the ongoing run rate. Ie it will need to plug a gap of over 2 months of accrued Tresaury issuance, and also to refund the retirement accounts it has been borrowing from to buy some more time.
SO we are looking at rising yields due to a decrease in demand, and a pretty hefty increase in supply.
We started seeing that last week, with the move in the 5 year the largest move in percentage points ...... EVER!!!
Perhaps the (temporary) rescue of Greece should convert the PIGS into PISA? I wonder who the A stands for ...... answers on a postcard!!!

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Why now?

There has got to be more to last weeks move by the IEA to release an additional 60 million barrels of oil than meets the eye. At the time of the announcement, WTI crude oil was sitting at about $95 – approximately 20% beneath its recent peak. A very big price adjustment had already been made. Had oil been trading at $120, it would be more understandable. Its only the 3rd time ever the IEA has tapped into their reserves: the first time was during the Gulf War, next was after hurricane Katrina, and now a third time. Why?

· One of the reasons given, is the production loss due to Libya. This doesn’t make much sense, as the story is a good couple of months old. Why act now? And in any event, currently the production lost due to Libya has been offset by the loss of demand from Japan post tsunami.
· Another proposed reason, is to clampdown on the speculative longs. Again, this is unlikely, as there were far more speculative longs a number of weeks ago when the price was $20 higher, and there was no “imminent” correction. Plus, any speculative longs out there must have nerves of steel, as the recent macro data is painting a picture of a world in which China, the US, Europe and Japan are all slowing down.
· It’s unlikely too that the reason is to stimulate the economy, be it the US, China or Europe. The 60 million barrels would last for about 16 hours of global consumption- hardly enough to make any sort of impact on global supply and lasting impact on price. Indeed, you will probably find China licking their lips in glee, at the ability to buy up every single one of those barrels for their own reserves.
· The IEA’s strategic reserves are specifically held for “emergency situations”. The IEA has no choice but to replenish the released reserves at some future time. I.e. additional price pressure at some future point.

In my mind, the release of the oil should be considered the equivalent of a global coordinated rate cut. In the long run, oil is an inflationary headwind but the elevated prices at the moment is more of a consumption tax and price shock. Last week’s events may merely be temporary) but I think they will serve a psychological purpose. However, the timing of the announcement, despite being odd as to the necessity, is also a little bit on the short sighted side. As reported 2 weeks ago http://goldrockthoughts.blogspot.com/2011/06/crude-to-march-higher.html
OPEC had their worst ever meeting, and there is already evidence of a strong rift within the OPEC camp. Since that meeting, Saudia Arabia have seemingly been cast into the sidelines, and OPEC themselves do not seem to consider the Saudi’s as a part of OPEC.

Where’s the evidence? OPEC and the European Union are due to hold an energy summit in Vienna Monday that will be the first official meeting of producers and consumers since the IEA's move, and will provide a platform for OPEC members to express their disquiet over the stocks' release. However, OPEC's biggest player, Saudi Arabia, won't be present. There has to be at least the potential for the remaining OPEC countries to counteract the IEA’s move and cut output to offset the increased supply. A war in which OPEC cuts production and IEA offsets that with the release of strategic reserves, is not a situation that the global economy would like to get into right now. (Besides for China of course, who would happily build up its own strategic reserves).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEGAL DISCLAIMER: The views mentioned above are purely that of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the official view of Goldrock Capital or employees. Unless of course the aforementioned view was a phenomenally good call, with exquisite market timing, in which case Goldrock Capital reserves the right to all credit!!!!!More Serious disclaimer:The financial advice offered on this site is of a general nature and may not be suitable for some people. No individual financial needs or goals have been taken into account in the advice offered on this site, you should always seek independent advice about specific financial decisions. Neither Goldrock Capital nor its employees makes or gives any representation, warranty or guarantee that the information it provides in this website is complete, accurate, current or reliable (including that it has been or will be audited or verified). Goldrock Capital and its employees shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, by one or more of the authorities, or incidental or consequential loss or damage) arising out of or in connection with any use or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information on this website is no substitute for financial advice.

Monday, June 20, 2011

Greece



One of our avid readers (hi Mum!) pointed out how we have failed to comment on the main story currently hitting all the headlines …. that of Greece. That is correct- probably the main reason is due to the fact that the news flowing out of Greece, is so fast, that I would have undoubtedly got to the end of my blogging, by which point I would have had to write a whole new posting due to an updated newsflash! Often, the latest revelation is a full 180° from the previous newsflash, and that is no doubt significantly contributing to the increasing volatility we have been privy to, with investors being whipsawed from one side to the other! Risk on, risk off, threat of contagion, restructurings, haircuts ….. isn’t life exciting! The other reason for not writing about Greece, is that I would undoubtedly have to disclose that my main ECONOMICS tutor was Greek, and what does that say about my knowledge of economics/finance?!!! Truth is, he was also my Football Manager ……. And he was a darn sight better at football than at Economics!!!

What is clear, is that Greece has run out of money, again, and needs some form of bailout/restructuring. So far, Europe, the ECB, IMF and everyone else has responded to the problem by throwing more money at Greece, allowing them to "buy time". Nobody has used the downright rude and ugly term of "insolvent", with "liquidity" being the preferred terminology. Lenders have been willing to lend more money, because the problem is one of liquidity. They have been willing to lend more money to banks and Governments. And Greece for their part, have not once admitted the need for default or restructuring, and so the banking sectors have not been forced to write down any more debt and/or need to raise more capital. A win win for everyone.

This would have bought some more time. Time is a fantastic healer. However, the issue was not one of liquidity, rather one of insolvency-debt problems are unlikely to be solved by taking on more debt. As a minimum, investors will require a credible plan for the economy to return to solvency to become willing to fund the banks and public debt of the troubled economy in question. This does not seem to be the case though, with the general Greek population revolting (in the other sense of the word), then one has to wonder where that credible solvency plan is going to come from. What is clear though, is that of those included around the negotiating table, nobody but nobody is "allowing" Greece to simply default. A solution will seemingly be found to prevent Greece from "legally" defaulting- even if it means some quick changes to EU law, account rules or ECB operation guidelines.

Whats the big deal with a Greek default? Why are they working so hard to prevent it? The Eurozone debt crises, is not especially extraordinary- it is merely another credit cycle, whereby debt extends beyong the capacity of consumers and economies. Debt then contracts as uncollectable debt gets written down, and bad debt is purged from the system. Throwing more money at Greece is merely extending and prolonging the problem?

Although a default is a default, and from a value point of view it doesn’t make any difference whether it is the debt of Greece, Portugal, Azerbaijan or the US that is written down, from an economic point of view, it certainly makes a difference. If Greece are thrown another lifeline, both Ireland and Portugal will operate under the assumption that in the future, they will also get another bailout should they need it. Markets know that, and hence speculation will continue on the "Who's next path", and cause investors to demand additional premiums, causing yields to rise. Eventually, the larger economies will be targeted too. How do I know you wont default either Spain? And that will cause even more serious problems, as who is left to bailout the larger and more important economies?






---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEGAL DISCLAIMER: The views mentioned above are purely that of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the official view of Goldrock Capital or employees. Unless of course the aforementioned view was a phenomenally good call, with exquisite market timing, in which case Goldrock Capital reserves the right to all credit!!!!!More Serious disclaimer:The financial advice offered on this site is of a general nature and may not be suitable for some people. No individual financial needs or goals have been taken into account in the advice offered on this site, you should always seek independent advice about specific financial decisions. Neither Goldrock Capital nor its employees makes or gives any representation, warranty or guarantee that the information it provides in this website is complete, accurate, current or reliable (including that it has been or will be audited or verified). Goldrock Capital and its employees shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, by one or more of the authorities, or incidental or consequential loss or damage) arising out of or in connection with any use or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information on this website is no substitute for financial advice.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

A contrarian view ......

Interestingly, after my last blog entry http://goldrockthoughts.blogspot.com/2011/06/taking-look-at-bigger-picture.html I saw that the 10 day smooth moving average for the put/call ratio was at its highest it has been since March 2009 when the S&P put in its 666 low.

As a reminder, the put to call ratio is a popular contrarian indicator based upon the trading volumes of put options compared to call options. The ratio attempts to gauge the prevailing level of bullishness or bearishness in the market. Obviously, there is always a buyer for every seller, otherwise the market wouldn’t clear. On days when the major averages perform strongly, the number of calls bought typically far outweighs the number of puts, so the ratio tends to be small. On days of market weakness, fear prevails and the number of puts purchased is typically much higher. The daily put/call graph is highly erratic, however, a moving average that smoothes out the data is an excellent contrarian tool that can help you avoid getting caught up in the prevailing market sentiment.




A 1 day rise in the indicator is typically a sign that investors are temporarily seeking protection against a market decline, an extreme high in the moving average reveals a more comprehensive sentiment build-up. The put/call ratio hit its highest level in the last 2 and a half years, higher than this time last year when the market first plunged on Greece, and higher than March 2009 when the market hit the 666 low.




































I always like mentioning the other side of the coin too, and so yes, this is a favored contrarian tool, never before has the put/call ratio been at such extreme levels DESPITE the multi-trillion safety net in the form of central banks, and just 2 weeks prior to the end of the Fed stimulus program. Contrarian tools are a good bet against conventional wisdom. However, with Greece/Europe on the verge of bankruptcy, perhaps conventional wisdom (continued declines in the markets) will prevail after all!!!



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEGAL DISCLAIMER: The views mentioned above are purely that of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the official view of Goldrock Capital or employees. Unless of course the aforementioned view was a phenomenally good call, with exquisite market timing, in which case Goldrock Capital reserves the right to all credit!!!!!More Serious disclaimer:The financial advice offered on this site is of a general nature and may not be suitable for some people. No individual financial needs or goals have been taken into account in the advice offered on this site, you should always seek independent advice about specific financial decisions. Neither Goldrock Capital nor its employees makes or gives any representation, warranty or guarantee that the information it provides in this website is complete, accurate, current or reliable (including that it has been or will be audited or verified). Goldrock Capital and its employees shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, by one or more of the authorities, or incidental or consequential loss or damage) arising out of or in connection with any use or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information on this website is no substitute for financial advice.

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Taking a look at the bigger picture ,,,,,,,

I thought I’d take advantage of a quiet day in the office and catch up with some blogging ……. There’s not many people who can openly say that without fear of their employer giving them “the boot”- not only do I not have that fear, but I know I have my employer’s blessing ….. wow! I’d like to take a step back and see where we are. Not that one should only reflect on quieter days, but its certainly a good opportunity to do just that!

With the US markets currently down some 8% from the recent peak, with the Nasdaq in negative territory for the year and many other markets either share a similar fate or are fast approaching, there is certainly a lot of fear out there. What do we do now? Do we buy? Sell and wait for more certainty before getting back in? Wait and see? The first question that needs to be addressed is what sort of an investor am I? Many investors are currently wondering why they are not traders. The last decade has seen the markets go absolutely nowhere with a huge amount of volatility. Buy and hold has not worked in the main. One must remember though, that:

1. yes, your neighbor may have sold at the top, but if they didn’t get back in, then they are not necessarily better off.
2. You have many neighbors, many more of whom would have bought at the top ….
3. and it’s only the successful ones that will be shouting their stories!

Generally, trying to mix the trader and investor approaches does not work. If you would like some blend of the 2, you should allocate part of your money to each method as the rules and psychology are completely different. The trader MUST NOT care about fundamental values- his timeframe is far too short. The investor has to trade on fundamentals, without getting caught up by the emotive side. Indeed, the investor will typically be buying the stocks that are hated by the market in general and traders in particular.

The Markets have had a very negative tone over the last few weeks. This was to be expected. In Q1:
· Cyclical indicators reached historically high levels, and was tracking well above its normal level for the stage of recovery we were at.
· Consumer confidence was dented by a whole host of problems.
· High commodity prices were denting the consumers and putting corporate margins under pressure, but the weak consumer meant that companies were unable to fully pass on the costs.
· Wage costs are rising sharply in Emerging Markets.
· Productivity growth is unlikely to be strong due to the lack of investment over the last 3 years.
· Forecasts, which on the whole had been based on continued positive margin expansion was already at the highest since 1956, despite a tepid economy and surging input costs.
· Emerging Market Central banks have started on the monetary tightening route.

And we haven’t even begun to talk about outside factors, such as the end to QE2 and Fed induced liquidity, or the sovereign debt problems that have plagued us for 18 months and show no signs of letting up, or geopolitical tension in the Middle East/Africa, or natural disasters/tsunamis and their repercussions on global demand/supply, or a housing market is bobbing along at the very bottom, with 1 in 4 Americans in negative equity with potentially much more downside, or even the still weak labor market.

There is no doubt about it, the economy is definitely cooling off, as it was this time last year. However, now it is different. Last year, Mr Bernanke through the market a lifeline with a new round of liquidity expansion. Last week however, he delivered an even more sobering outlook, but this time without the lifeline (just yet anyway- I mentioned here
http://goldrockthoughts.blogspot.com/2011/06/what-goes-up-must-come-down.html that the stock market, and Fed, and just about everyone in between is seemingly caught in a catch 22 situation: QE3 is seemingly being priced in by stocks ...... however for QE3 to actually happen, stocks would have to fall approximately 15-20% from their current elevated levels!!! I feel that QE3 was the main factor in propping up the market to such an elevated level, if there is no hint from the next Fed meeting (next week) as to the onset of QE3, we may be in for an interesting market- which of course would give the Fed the ammo needed for QE3!!!

Another interesting observation is that whilst the economists have been cutting their numbers, the equity analysts have yet to follow suit. If they do, then suddenly market valuations are not as compelling as they seemed.

All this sounds very bearish, and one can well understand the want/need to take some money off the table and wait and see. Weakness in the economic data was expected. In addition, the supply chain disruptions from Japan and consumer cutbacks from higher oil, was also expected, with consensus opinion that the tepid recovery will continue after these aberrations. There is always the worry though that the economic weakness is the sign of something much worse. This currently seems quite an extreme view, as even the cautious camp are predicting a slower rate of growth rather than an outright recession.

There are some real doom and gloomers too, who want to extrapolate to another lost decade plus. For me, the last decade was an exception. It started where demand and sales had been brought forward over fears of Y2k. This was an exceptional and unprecedented boom, which was only intensified by the onset of the internet. The decade ended with a financial crises of unprecedented proportions. We started with an atypical peak, and ended with an atypical trough.

For the investors out there, I would take advantage of the fear. Though I would imagine that there is still some more downside, I feel like the slowing economy story is fairly reflected in prices. Over the course of a business cycle, stocks are undervalued and trading below historic norms. Yes, China, and other Emerging countries are tightening, but this is a positive. They have already been appropriately tightening for a year now, and seem to be successfully navigating growth with manageable inflation. Incremental Emerging Market consumer spending eclipsed US consumer spending several years ago, with the Emerging Market consumer to drive global growth for years to come. And there are already indications that even those who have been hardest hit by the Japanese earthquake are almost operating close to full production.

Over the past few months, I have been saying how the market is not exciting, the risk reward is not compelling. The markets are now at their most compelling, valuation wise. Despite expecting some more down side, I would begin to close underweights and for the investors to build positions. The markets themselves seem quite healthy, in the sense of strong balance sheets, leverage as low as it has been for the last 20 years, banks more willing to lend, buisness climate indicators still close to their highs. By all means trade the fear, trade the exuberance. But don’t get caught up in it yourself. Stick to your system- if everything is within normal ranges, then there is no reason for alarm. And also be wary of the news. The news is about problems and potential disasters. If it’s the talk of the town, then it is already reflected in market prices. Look for the unexpected, or if something unusual is happening.

Happy Investing/trading!!!



For the record, S&P 500 currently at 1267!


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------LEGAL DISCLAIMER: The views mentioned above are purely that of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the official view of Goldrock Capital or employees. Unless of course the aforementioned view was a phenomenally good call, with exquisite market timing, in which case Goldrock Capital reserves the right to all credit!!!!!

More Serious disclaimer:

The financial advice offered on this site is of a general nature and may not be suitable for some people. No individual financial needs or goals have been taken into account in the advice offered on this site, you should always seek independent advice about specific financial decisions. Neither Goldrock Capital nor its employees makes or gives any representation, warranty or guarantee that the information it provides in this website is complete, accurate, current or reliable (including that it has been or will be audited or verified). Goldrock Capital and its employees shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, by one or more of the authorities, or incidental or consequential loss or damage) arising out of or in connection with any use or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information on this website is no substitute for financial advice.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Thank you Stanley!!

I note that Stanley Fischer has put himself forward as a candidate for the top-job at the IMF.

As opposed to some of the Israeli papers who consider this to be almost treasonable, that he leave the job in the middle of the second term, I would like to wish him the best of luck!!

What an honour it would be if the next IMF head came direct from the Bank of Israel.

By the way, it ought not need saying, but he has done a great job as Governor and I thank him for that!!

Let's be a little gracious to our public servants (at least on the odd occasion when they do they job right!!)